Topper Copies

Discuss the principles of diffusionism in anthropology, focusing on the contributions of Grafton Elliot Smith and W.H.R. Rivers. How did these early diffusionists explain cultural similarities and differences among societies?

Aditya Vikram Agarwal, AIR 9, 2024

Diffusionesm is a school of thought which seeks to understand culture vis -a-vis its origins and spread of cultural traits.

Principles of diffusionism

- Important inventions are made at particular places from where they spread to other parts of the world. - Humans are mainly imitators and rather inventors.

They were critical of the idea of cultural classical evolutionists concept of unilinear and sequential development of culture. They also rejected the concept of 'psychic unity of mankind' giving independent innovations

Contribution of the following in British school of diffusionism :-

1. G.E. Smith : He studied various cultural elements of different civilisation and found that all of them displayed the same basic form of Egyptian prototypes. As Egypt was the ancient cradle of civilisation, he concluded that the Egypt was the only center of culture from where culture diffused to other parts of the world. 2. WHR Rivers : He sought to explain the contrast between Melanian and polynesian cultures. In his book, 'The History of Melanesian society (1914)', he opined that cultural similarities could be better explained by the diffusion and migration of traits. He also said that culture can progress and degenerate both. This way was opposite to the classical evolunists's theory.

The deffusionists conducted fieldwork and also relied on historical data to reconstruct paths of diffusion and migration of culture. Torres Strait Expedition (1899) established fieldwork as important part of anthropological research.

Explanation of cultural similarities and differences

-> According to diffusionists, the cultural similarities between two cultures can be explained by the existence of similar traits among them. This was due to migration of traits from one society to other. -> The differences among the societies could be explained by modification of borrowed traits to suit the environment.

Criticism of the diffusionist school

- The British school with its heliocentric view and terming Egypt as the only center of culture was criticised. - It failed to explain the how similar traits were observed in two geographically remote places that had no means of communication. - Studying of cultural traits in isolation rather integrated whole.

Despite its criticism, the theory has been helpful in understanding the spread of ideas. The concepts of sacred complex, sacred centres and universalization of little and great traditions were inspired by it.