Topper Copies

Religion vs. Magic.

Aditya Vikram Agarwal, AIR 9, 2024

Frazer, in his book, 'The Golden Bough (1890)' shows that the religion is next stage of development after magic in societies. Acc to him, magic was a technique used in early stage to compel supernatural to do one's own bidding. Religion was born out of new found conviction that higher power governs the universe.

Similarities

- Acc. to Malinowski, they help in alleviating stress and anxiety in face of uncertainity. - Both represent integrative needs. - Both require performance of some technique / ritual based on non-verified results.

Differences

(i) Magic involves coercion while religion involves supplication as per Frazer. (ii) As per Malinowski , magic is simple with limited technique and practical orientation whereas religion is complex. The religion is based on rituals and belief and is more value oriented. (iii) Durkheim referred religion as 'sacred' as it is set apart from routine activities through rituals and dogmas. Meanwhile magic is 'profane' as it deals with mundane activities. (iv) Religion has large body of worshippers unlike magic. (v) Religion does not guarantee results and based on faith and devotion. (vi) Religious pronouncements find meaning in the language.

Religion and magic today are being replaced by more empirical techniques of science based on facts and reason.