Topper Copies

Critically evaluate the contesting theories of the emergence and dispersal of modern Homo sapiens.

Aditya Vikram Agarwal, AIR 9, 2024

The emergence and dispersal of modern Homo Sapiens is contested by two theories — Out of Africa and Multiregional hypothesis

Commonality between the two Both agree that Homo erectus originated in Africa and expanded to Eurasia about one million years ago.

Differences in the hypothesis They differ in the explaining of the origin of modern humans (Homo sapiens Sapiens).

1. Out of Africa hypothesis According to this Homo sapiens emerged from only one place i.e. Africa from where they migrated to the rest of the world.

Early proponents of this hypothesis were led by British Palaeontologist – Chris Stringer.

It proposes that a second migration out of Africa happened about 100,000 years ago in which anatomically modern humans of African origin conquered the world by completely replacing the archaic human population. (Model A)

A modified version of this hypothesis emphasises the African origin of most human population but allows for the possibility of minor local contributions. (Model B)

[drawn Models A and B: four lines numbered 1 – Africa, 2 – Europe, 3 – Asia, 4 – Oceania, running from H. erectus 1mn yr ago to H. sapiens 100,000 yrs ago]

2. Multiregional hypothesis It was proposed in 1984 by Milford H. Wolpoff, Alan Thorne, Xinzhi Wu.

It stated that Independent multiple origins (Model D) or shared multi-regional evolution with continuous gene flow between continent populations (Model C) occured in the million years since H. erectus came out of Africa.

Model D – implies that H. erectus of different continents gave rise to Archaic population of Humans independently who then gave rise to modern humans. (Eg) Archaic Asian H. erectus gave rise to Archaic asians which then gave rise to modern Asians. It does not account for possible mating between them – Asian or African/EU types.

Model C – accounts for all possible mating including within and between sub-species.

[drawn Models C and D: lines numbered 1 to 4 from H. erectus 1 mn yrs. to H. sapiens 100,000 yrs., Model C with crossing arrows between the lines, Model D without]

Present situation Ancient DNA evidences from Neanderthals, early modern humans in Europe and Africa have changed the understanding of modern human origins.

Today's modern humans of Eurasia derives most of their ancestry from bottlenecked population that existed 70,000 years ago. This populations has originated from African ancestor 150,000 years ago. This bottlenecked population mixed with neanderthals and another archaic human population, Denisovans.

The modern human population ultimately arrived throughout all the continents of the world.