How did H.H. Risley and B.S. Guha contribute to the understanding of racial identities in India through their classification systems? Analyze the critiques and limitations of both approaches in accurately representing the complex social fabric of the country.
Aditya Vikram Agarwal, AIR 9, 2024
Brainstorm
H.H. Risley — 'The People of India (1915)' 7-fold racial classification based on 9 anthropometric measurement. Major measurement criteria — nasal index
[a hand-drawn outline map of India with Risley's racial types marked 1 to 7]
Racial Types 1. Turko - Iranian 2. Indo - Aryan 3. Scytho - Dravidian 4. Aryo Dravidian 5. Mongolo Dravidian 6. Mongoloid 7. Dravidian
1. Afghanis, Baluchis – fair complexion, tall, medium nose 2. Kashmiri Pandits, Jats, Rajputs – fair, tall, long nose 3. Maratha Brahmins, Kunbis, Coorgs – fair, medium stature 4. UP, Bihar — light to brown complexion 5. Bengalis 6. epicanthic fold, flat face – Lepchas, Gurungs, Bodos 7. Paniyans of Malabar, Santhals.
Criticism - excessive focus on nasal index - limited sample size - Guha : Indo Aryan not limited to NW India - Undue importance to Scythian elements - Ignored Negrito element - Bengal – absence of epicanthic fold despite mongloid classification - South of vindhyas – categories as one (dravidian) despite differences.
B.S. Guha — Anthropometric data of 1931 census 6 - fold racial classification
1. Negrito — Kadar, Irulas, Paniyans 2. Proto Australoid – Santhal, Oraon, Chenchu 3. Mongoloid – Sema Nagas, Limbus, Chakmas 4. Mediterranean – Nair, Telugu Brahmins 5. western Brachycephals – Guj. Baniya, Bengali Kayasthes 6. Nordic – Punjab, Rajputana
[a hand-drawn outline map of India marked with Guha's racial element numbers by region]
Criticism - source of all racial groups traced outside of India - findings of Negrito elements – opposed by anthropologists { universally – negrito = tall but Guha = short