Critically discuss the reasons for sudden decline of Indus Valley Civilization
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
Indus valley civilisation (IVC) after lasting in its mature phase from 2600 BCE started to decline and ended in mature phase around 1800 BCE.
Reasons for decline of IVC
1. Aryan invasion as given by M. Wheeler et. al who argued that based on the skulls in Mohenjodaro and mention of Battle of Hariyupiya in Rig veda and Indra as 'Purandra' meaning breaker of forts', Aryans destroyed it - Criticism - No weapons found in any site of IVC - Skulls found were naturally dead - Aryans came in 1500 BCE, 300 years after decline
2. River regime changes : Some argue that Indus river changed course due to tectonic shift which caused the destruction of sites such as Mohenjodaro etc - Criticism - No such evidence of tectonic phenomena - Others sites that were not on Indus such as Harappa also declined why ?
3. Hydrological changes : Raikes and Dales argue that drying of Ghaggar-Hakra led to lesser water in Sutlej and Indus causing aridity and loss of agriculture. - Criticism - Not much difference in Indus due to drying of Ghaggar - No. Paleo-climatic evidence for drying of Co.haggar
4. Physico-chemical explosion as provided by Dmitriyev who argued a weather phenomena that led to black-clouds, lightning etc destroyed IVC sites - Criticism - No empirical evidence, - why all sites declined - Many sites such as Amri were later inhabited also.
5. Aridity & Climate Change : Climate models used by many such as IIT Madras showed that at the end of 1900-1800 BCE, climate became arid which must have caused loss of water in IVC - Criticism - why other civilisations didn't collapse at same time
Tony Joseph argues in Early Indians' that there may have been many factors behind decline but climate change sapped the vitality of IVC