Discuss the economic, political, social and cultural dimensions of structural disadvantages of tribes resulting from the subordination after their incorporation into larger social system
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
Tribes have been seen historically to have maintained a reasonable separation with the mainstream social system as found by Verrier Elwin .
But in the colonial times and later, they have been incorporated into the larger social systems as:
- Tribe - Caste Continuum given by F. G. Bailey argues that tribes have adopted many characteristics of caste as they came into contact and are no longer opposites . e.g: Bhumij of Baraboom studied by Surajit Sinha - Hindu Method of tribal absorption given by N. K. Bose argued that when tribes came into contact with their powerful neighbours, they lose their culture. - Others such as Haimendorf found the adoption of ploughs cultivation by Hill Reddis who turned into caste.
This has led to Structural disadvantages for the tribes in all dimensions:
Economic dimension
Due to subordination, tribes lost the traditional economic systems based on reciprocity etc as described by Majumdar and led to : - Indebtedness due to heavy expenditure (as found by SEARCH) and money lenders e.g : Thakurs & Bhoksas are indebted to Punjabi settlers - Poverty is at a high of 40.7% (NSSO) - Bonded labours and unemployment is rampant e.g: Kollas of Jemsar Banwar studied by Archi Rastogi are bonded.
Political dimension
Tribes found that their traditional political institutions such as Mohato, Pir-panchayat etc which had developed by an evolutionary process (as per PEARL study) is gone. - e.g: 29th Report of SC/ST commissioner argued that traditional panchayats are left alone with no support & Ideas
Social dimension
Traditionally, tribals had a seperate society but this subordination has led to, - change in marriage rules to rigid e.g: Gonds of Yavatmal studied by Prashant Bhansode have adopted dowry - Stratification has occured among tribes leading to breakage of kinship ties e.g: As found in Chodas of Gujarat by K.S. Singh
Cultural dimension
culture has changed from one based on reciprocity etc to a globalised culture : - loss of tribal crafts & markets e.g: loss of Bastar market - Forced culture of prostitution in some. - changed to westernised clothes etc e.g: Oraons
But, there has been a flip side for some tribes such as Meenas , Gonds etc who have gained high status & hence requires a holistic approach