Topper Copies

Discuss the Anthropological perspectives on the origins of caste India

Waseem Ahmad Bhat

The origin of caste in India has been the central discussion of caste studies since the colonial times

Anthropological perspectives on origins of Caste

- Purusha-Sukta Hymn in 10th Mandala of Rig veda described its origin based on birth of Castes from Brahma's head, arms, feet etc - Criticism - G.S.Ghurye argued that no empirical evidence - M.N.Srinivas — leaves out the harijans

European anthropologists

- Abbe Dubois argued in 'Brahminical theory' that Caste is a device created by the Brahmins for themselves - Criticism - No empirical evidence - why other castes believed it!

1. H. Risley gave the 'racial theory of castes' based on anthropometry such as 'nasal index'. He argued that caste originated when Aryans came to India and due to hypergamy and later endogamy, they closed ranks & became castes - Criticism - Nesfield — No racial difference b/w Brahmins & other castes - Hutton — Racism is universal, caste is not 2. Nesfield in his 'Brief view of caste' argued that caste originated in occupational division of labour where different occupational groups became castes. e.g: Metal working ones higher than basket weaving - criticism - Occupational division in other matrix didn't lead to caste

Indian response

(a) G.S. Ghurye argued that caste originated in race & occupation stabilised it. He believed that 'Brahmin prospectors' from UP, Bihar etc went to other parts of India and spread caste.

(b) Ambedkar in 'who are shudras' argued that caste originated in parcelling of an already homogenous unit in racial terms.

(c) S.V. Ketkar argued that caste originated based on outcomes of early tribal conflicts.

New genetic evidences such as by Kaur et al of Y-DNA and Reich et.al have showed that complex origin of caste may have been based on the sex selective admixtures and endogamy. Thus, S.C. Roy argues that there were multiple factors