Describe the integrationists approaches to caste with emphasis on M. Marriot
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
Caste of India has been studied from multiple perspectives including structural views of G. Besseman etc and cultural view of Louis Dumont , Massiot etc .
Integrationist approach takes an integrated view of caste system as a Social stratification that is rigid but also a unique Indian form of inequality as follows:
- Gerald Besseman argued that not viewing Caste in an structural form leads to loss of its Comparative power - He argues that studies of Rwanda by Maquet , Burakamin of Japan etc and Swat valley by Barth can be the initial points of comparison. - Macquet shoreep presence of 'caste' in structural terms among Rwanda between Tutsi, Hutu, Twa with birth based ascription, endogamy etc - C. Bougle, on the other hand, argued that while 'caste' may be present in other societies but real 'caste spirit' is present only in India.
- Later Louis Dumont argued that the 3 characteristics of caste given by Bougle have dichotomy of pure-impure as their defining feature.
(i) McKim Marriot in this context gave an integrationist approach called as 'Interactional theory' of caste, ethnosociological view etc based on his study of Konduru village of Andhra.
- He argued that Dumont's attributional theory cannot be used to decipher local hierarchy. He argued that hierarchy is based on transactions — the purest form of 'coded bodily substances' one receives, the higher in rank one is - According to him, Brahmins derive their high rank based on 'pure forms' of food and services from other castes and give services in return e.g: food is not taken uncooked.
This gave a holistic approach, an integrationist view of caste that led to 'indigenous models' of caste theories