Cultural Pluralism and Uniform Civil Code
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
cultural pluralism is the presence of multiple cultures that mix and match within a society. In India, this pluralism has created a debate about need of UCC under Art 44
Cultural pluralism and UCC
While UCC is important for the following reasons :
1. To ensure equal rights for all women irrespective of the community (Art 14) 2. To curb the tendencies of communal clashes based on perceived legal benefits 3. To curb fraudulent conversions only for polygamy SC in Sarla Mudgal case
But cultural pluralism depicts another side :
- Cultural relativists agree that different cultural practices cannot be measured by a pan-cultural standard - Freedom of religion (Act 25-28) may be abrogated by UCC as it will curb religious practices of different religions - Different cultural practices such as tribes of North east are protected under Art 371 and cannot be stopped .
As Law Commission Report pointed out, 'unity without uniformity' is what is needed which requires codification of laws of different cultural groups .