Discuss the closed social stratification in India. Is there any change in this in modern India?
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
P. Gisbert described Social Stratification as the division of a society into permanent groups who are related to each other by the process of subordination and hierarchy'.
Social Stratification in India
Indian society has traditionally been described as a stratified society based on closed endogamous groups (Sujit Sinha). The stratification can be discussed as : - Louis Dumont argued that caste system was more than a Social Stratification; It was a system of hierarchy based on 'purity and pollution'. This purity is determined by attributes such as vegetarianism, teetotalism etc
=> Max Weber believed that closed social stratification was explicitly based on Religious sanctions and hence Indian Society is an 'ideal type'
=> later G.S. Ghurye in his work 'Caste, Race and language in India' described the stratification based on characteristics such as
=> Further M.N. Srinivas differentiated between book view & field view
Changes in modern India
Due to globalisation, industrialisation, many things have changed : - Equality rather than hierarchy (Art 15, 16) - More Commensality due to urbanisation, politics etc - Changing dynamics of neo-feminisation led to change of status of lower castes [Andre Beteille in Tanjore] - Caste has reduced in terms of occupational division of labour as seen in breakdown of jajmani system [Otten and Simpson]
Yet anthropologists such as Ganesham Shah [?] M. N. Srinivas etc have argued that only Caste system is dying ; Caste is alive ' due to politicization of caste and changing identities of caste as class [K.L. Sharma]