Globalization is an unavoidable alternative for modernism and postmodernism. Discuss
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
While modernism is the belief in detachment and objective assessment of phenomena, postmodernism describes the lack of any culturally tinged knowledge (e.g: Hans Georg Gadamer).
Both of these have faced criticism over the years in anthropology :
criticism of modernism - [Foucault] argued in 'Discourses on power' that all social relations are characterised by dominance and subordination. ↳ Hence, objective assessment is not possible - [Derrida] argued that ethnographies had presuppositions, bias etc which is to be deconstructed - Renato Rosaldo argued that 'Headhunters rage', that the assesor (ethnographer) places the locals in his cultural model -> ethnocentric
Criticism of postmodernism Postmodernism has its fair share of criticisms : - Melford Spiro argues that Subjectivity is bound to happen even in postmodernism - Roy. D'Andrade argues in 'Moral models' that postmodernists donot understand objectivity and all these models are moral models - Marvin Harris in 'Anthropological theories in Postmodern times' argued that postmodernism will have severe political repercussions
Globalisation as the alternative to both Anthony Giddens defined globalisation as the 'integration of world regions and cultures based on trade, commerce and connectivity.' It is an alternative as : - Integrates both modernism and postmodernism e.g. In economic anthropology, Plattner argues that an integrated approach is needed in the globalised world to understand world economy as a whole. - It resolves the apparent contradiction of both by both emic and etic perspective e.g: Lila Abu Lughod described both her pregnancy and that of Egyptian Bedouin friends - Globalisation fosters an [?] acculturation process which leads to cultural sensitiveness
In this context, what is needed is a form of glocalisation with both emic and etic perspectives for a holistic understanding of cultures.