Critically compare the views of E.B.Tylor and Max Muller on Religion
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
E.B.Tylor defined Religion as 'Belief in Spiritual beings' which is a minimum definition of Religion -
His difference with Max Muller on religion can be described as
| E.B.Tylor | Max Muller | |---|---| | He had an evolutionary approach to Religion: Animism -> Polytheism -> Monotheism | He also had the same approach but believed nature worship to be the first religion: Naturism -> Polytheism -> Monotheism | | He believed that early man had the concept of 'Soul' and that led Him to animism which believes that everything is animated | He argued that naturism was based on the belief in the procreative powers of nature -> voices is in the intellectual capacity of early man . | | Described nature worship as one of the stages that connected fetishism to polytheism . | No such belief |
But beyond differences, they also had similarities : - Both are from evolutionary school - Both were criticized as 'armchair anthropologists' due to lack of primary data
Nowadays, evolutionary school has made a comeback as seen in researches into animism (e.g: Frank Marlowe in 2016)