Topper Copies

The genetic endowments which permit the acquisition and maintenance of culture are the property of the human species as a whole, not of any one race. Comment

Waseem Ahmad Bhat

Culture was defined by E.B.Tylor as the 'whole notions and behaviour that a man learns as part of society'. This anthropological understanding of culture as a phenomenon of all societies of humans was a new one.

Earlier understanding Race theorists such as Herodotus, Plato, Aristotle argued that the endowments which led to culture were only present in the European cultures (Greek) and other populations lived like beasts

This racism has since been denied as follows: - Leslie White argued that five attributes that allow humans to make culture are : - Opposable thumb - Encephalisation - Speech - Tool use - Symbolism

-> Present in all human populations - later Richard Lewontin in 1980s found that only around 15% of genetic differences are intergroup and 85% are between individuals. - Human Genome Project by Collins found that humans everywhere are similar in around 99.9% of their genetic makeup making any racial comparisons ludicrous.

Culture as property of all humans This can be seen from development of cultures all around from tribes to Civilisations. e.g.: Kings have culture as rich as Americans - A. Toynbee found that major cultures/civilisations came up after race crossing Seen as Indian, Babylonian, Syriac etc - Shows collective endeavours

-> Thus UNESCO's 1952 Statement on Race argued : - we are one Species : Homo Sapiens - Racial differences does not in any way lessen the Contribution of some. They are only adaptations - Human culture is of human race as a whole.

As Ashley Montagu has argued, this fallacy needs to rooted out Sooner the better.