Give an account of several explanations offered to explain the transition from hunting and gathering to agriculture
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
Hunting and gathering has been described as the earliest mode of subsistence (that was the only one till 11,700 years ago) but it later led to agriculture .
To explain this multiple theories have been attempted :
- Oasis theory given by Gordon V. Childe argues that due to drying trend at the end of Holocene , it led to lesser precipitation . ↳ with human ascend Oasis with less food, they were forced to develop agriculture
[a hand-drawn world map of the centres of agriculture]
↳ criticism : Robert Braidwood argued that : 1. Climate change was not as harsh as potrayed 2. why didn't humans develop this system earlier in interglacial periods ?
- Readiness hypothesis by Robert Braidwood who argues that it was not climate change but humanity developed agriculture only when they had learnt sufficiently about their environment which lead to readiness around 11,000 years ago ↳ criticism : 1. why not all places ? (e.g : Not in Papua New Guinea)
- Kent- Flannery model's given by Kent and Flannery who argued that as population increased in some areas, people developed new modes of subsistence.
- Mark Cohen model given by Cohen argues that hunters-gatherers were 'filling up the world' and the displacement from 'optimum areas' led to new, less desirable sources such as agriculture.
- Broad-Spectrum collection theory given by Cohen and Stiner argued that at the end of holocene, due to death of Pleistocene megafauna, smaller animals and grasses were harvested (e.g: Natufians) which lead to knowledge of agriculture
- Jared Diamond in 'Guns, Germs and Steel' argues that multiple factors were responsible such as geography, demography etc