Discuss the conservative and creative aspects of selection
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
Natural selection is the gamut of processes that change the allele frequency due to differential reproductive success [Robert Fisher]
Selection though commonly understood as a creative force that leads to 'descent with modification' [as depicted by Darwin], it is infact both conservative & creative as :
Conservative aspects
1. Stabilising selection which is a form of selection which acts against the extreme genotypes and maintains the 'normal' -type. e.g.: low and high birth weights of neonatal infants is selected against
[a bell-shaped graph of stabilising selection, arrows pressing in from both sides against extremes, a narrower dashed curve inside]
- Dollo's rule also argues that once a organ system is developed, it is not easy to replace it e.g: loss of tail in humans.
↳ S. J. Gould argues that once broad forms emerge, they tend to be conserved and act as constraints
Creative aspects
This depicts the following : - Directional Selection : where selection may favour a rare allele which may then dominate to create new forms e.g: Industrial melanism as studied by [Kettlewell]
[a graph of directional selection, a bell-shaped curve with a dashed curve shifted right labelled 'new form']
- Disruptive selection also shows creative powers when the mean form is disrupted leading to two divergent populations e.g: Batesian mimicry in moths/butterflies
[a graph of disruptive selection, a bell-shaped curve with a dashed bimodal curve, 'new forms' at the right]
Other creative aspects can be seen in the balanced selection as seen in lack of elimination of genetic disorders as Down's syndrome due to antibiotic use
Thus, as [Chris Stringer] argues, natural selection is acting even currently in all its creative fashion to facilitate adaptation.