Concept of embeddedness and Karl Polanyi
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
Karl Polanyi in his book 'The Great Transformation' (1944) described in great detail the concept of embeddedness which is that the 'economic decisions in simple societies are embedded in their socio-cultural decisions'
He argued that this is why formalism i.e., application of normal economic laws can't be applied to simple societies.
Concept of embeddedness : Origin and development
Polanyi studied Malinowski who argued that in Trobriand 'islanders', economic decision making was based on decisions that are social in nature such as prestige and Relations ↳ His 'anti economics' approach influenced Polanyi to put forward his concept as: - In simple societies, economics is not a separate sphere but an integrated form of society. - Economic decisions are not based on 'utility' or 'marginal utility' or rationality but other social considerations such as kinship, love, prestige etc.
=> Others such as [Dalton], [Sahlins] also agreed and argued that in simple societies, economics is just the 'provisioning of society'.
Criticism
- [Burling] argued that formalism only argued that 'utility' is the goal but the goal could be any cultural goal. - Others such as [Plattner] argued that an integrated approach is needed in the modern globalised era when there are no simple societies