Topper Copies

Analyse the substantivist and formalist view in economic anthropology.

Laghima Tiwari

Economic anthropology refers to the study of economic systems of simple societies in their socio-cultural context.

- Formalists: They held that economy of simple societies should be studied by specialised economists. - Eg:- Raymond Firth, Herskovitz, Schneider - Substantivists: They held that anthropologists are best suited for studying economy of simple societies - Eg:- Sahlins, Polanyi

Formalist view

1. They held that economic principles of demand and supply, profit maximisation and conspicuous consumption are also valid in simple societies 2. Hence, assistance of specialised economists is required.

Criticism

1. As sahlins quote - 'Tribes are not maximisers, but optimisers' Eg - Kuikuru Indians of Amazon could earn profit by producing surplus if they work 1-2 hours more / day. But they still just stick to 3-4 hours of working 2. Dominance of kinship and concern for socio-cultural relations even in economic sphere. Is sahlins quote - "What money is to the west, kinship is to the rest' 3. Role of religion - LP Vidyarthi's study of N-M-S complex substantiates this view.

Substantivists.

1. They hold that tribal societies are not guided by modern principles of economics, and hold Kinship relations at centre. 2. Polanyi through his 'The Great Transformation' (1944) and sahlins Through - 'Stone Age Economics' (1972) show that.

Criticism

1. Not all tribal societies follow Keep Kenship relation over priority. 2. They are also guided by 'demand and supply'. Eg:- Trade exchange between inland kung and coastal Bantu.

The debate between two schools should be used to enrich the school of economic anthropology in totality.