Topper Copies

How do diffusionism and evolutionism differ as explanations of culture change?

Laghima Tiwari

Diffusionism and evolutionism both talk about cultural change, i.e., how societies evolve from simple to complex. However, they differ on their basic principles as to what causes this change.

| Diffusionism | Evolutionism | |---|---| | 1) It originated as reaction to classical evolutionists neglect of diffusion. | 1) Classical evolutionists were influenced by Darwin's book on biological evolution | | 2) It held that societies have changed through exchange and assimilation of ideas from other cultures. | 2) It held that societies all around the world change from simple to complex in a unilineal fashion. | | 3) It rejects psychic unity of mankind | 3) It upholds psychic unity as cause of change. | | 4) British and German school held that culture developed only in limited parts - Eg:- Egypt (British school) & few culture-centres [a sketch of concentric ovals labelled culture-centre] | 4) culture developed independently in each society. | | 5) Change can be both progressive and regressive - 'Degeneration theory' of Rivers in study of Melanesia | 5) Change is only progressive and variation is because different societies are at different stages. Savagery -> Barbarism -> civilisation | | 6) conducted fieldwork especially American school ; Boas used museum methodology | 6) No fieldwork, used comparative method to study change | | 7) scholars :- British - Smith, Rivers; German - schmidt, Ratzel; American - Wissler, Kroeber, Boas; culture-circle, agearea | 7) Scholars - Morgan, Tylor, Frazer . |

Neo-evolutionism developed as reaction to criticism of evolutionary school by diffusionists. It incorporated diffusion as cause of cultural change. It also stressed on importance of field -work.