Topper Copies

Critically compare the views of E.B.Tylor and Max Muller on Religion

Laghima Tiwari

E B Tylor gave the animic view in his 'Primitive Culture' (1871) while Max Muller gave Naturalism theory in his 'Lectures of on origin and growth of religion' (1878)

Similarity

1. Both regarded impact of surrounding environment on emergence of religion. 2. Evolution of religion :- Both gave a common scheme of

Differences

| E B Tylor | Max Muller | |---|---| | 1) He regarded belief in soul and dual existence as origin of religion | 1) He regarded origin of religion to be the same, threat and curiosity surrounding natural phenomena | | 2) Held that early man was a philosopher | 2) Held that early man just devised religion to decipher nature; not a philosopher | | 3) Eg:- Present day belief in shraddha & moksha | 3) Eg:- Different gods:- Indra - rain Varun - Water Agni - fire etc |

Apart from these Marrett's animism Comte's fetishism and Durkheim's Totemism also hold importance