Briefly discuss various theories of organic evolution
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
Herbert Spencer described organic evolution as the 'change from undifferentiated form to a developed differentiated form'. Though Charles Darwin is considered as the 'real father of organic evolution' but many theories have been given.
Pre Darwinian theories
1. Catastrophic theories by Georges Cuvier which argued that catastrophe in past lead to extinction of many species (e.g.: Noah's flood) - criticism - No evidence why fossils of living species are found. 2. Lamarckian theory propounded by Lamarck in 'Philosophie Zoologique' in 1907 argued that 'acquired characters were inherited' through generations (e.g: long neck of Giraffe due to its effort to reach tree tops -> then inherited - criticism ✕ — August Weismann cut the tail of rats for 20 gens and found that tail was not lost ; Differentiated germplasm and cytoplasm - Others such as Lysenko failed to prove it
Darwin's theory of natural selection
Described in his book 'Origin of Species' is essentially described by him as 'descent with modification' due to overproduction, variation , competition and survival of fittest
- criticism — Survival of fittest proven wrong -> why death of weakest - No concept of mutation - Why such long horns in Irish deer ? - Theory of Pangenesis wrong
Post Darwinian
1. Theory of mutationism by Hugo De Vries argued that mutation leads to direct change in species, as studied in evening primrose plant. - later led to 'punctuated equilibrium' by S. J. Gould etc. - criticism —— No such evidence - —— Against molecular evidences 2. Synthetic theory by scholars like R. Fisher, Dobzhansky etc - that combined Mendelism with Darwinism: - Genes are the agents of heredity - Mutation is the raw material - change is gradual by natural selection & genetic drift
∴ This is the most accepted theory but 21st century is seeing a new form emerge