Techno-Environmental determinism in Anthropological theories
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
Anthropological studies earlier used to take synchronic approaches and historically particularistics explanations (e.g: Franz Boas) but later studies moved to techno-environmental determinism i.e., culture determined by technology & environment.
Techno environmental determinism in anthropological studies
- Neo-evolutionists such as White and Steward used this method to argue that 'culture is an adaptation to environment'. - Leslie White argued that technology to extract energy determines the cultural efficiency in [E × T = C] → culture.
- Julian Steward gave cultural ecology model to argue that subsistence practices are based on environmental determinism which leads to 'peripheral culture' - cultural materialism by Marvin Harris used techno-environmental determinism to describe how infrastructure and structure affects superstructure of religion. - e.g: Cow ban in India based on its draught value as India is agricultural.
Criticism
- Discounts individual action e.g: wars etc - Postmodernists argue that cultures cannot be measured , But this approach have led to a new form of nomothetic methodology in anthropology