Slums are not 'problems' that have to be 'solved' – but are indeed a result of lopsided and vested urban policies covering infrastructure provision and socio-economic issues. Analyse.
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
The role of "slums" and "slum-dwellers" in making a city run is widely acknowledged, yet cities in recent past have been apathetic to slums.
Slums are not "problems" that have to be "solved".
1. Slum-dwellers provide crucial services to the city: safai karamcharis, security services (eg:) watchmen, etc, availability of produce across local markets (eg:) fish in Mumbai 2. The problem is poor governance, poor urban planning and poor urban infra
In fact, slums can be a part of the SOLUTION, as Odisha's JAGA Mission shows.
Slums are a result of lopsided and vested urban policies:
1. Unplanned expansion of urban areas 2. Lack of affordability of urban housing due to vested interests (local builder-politician-mafia nexus) 3. Poor public transportation, not following model of Transit-Oriented Development 4. Lack of provision of basic amenities in slums (eg:) water supply, electricity, etc 5. Failure to understand "seasonal migration" or "circular migration"; no support systems for migrants in urban areas 6. Socio-economic factors: lack of support system for women. Acc to M/o Women and Child Development, sexual abuse/violence is higher in urban areas than in rural areas 7. Higher inflation, cost of living in urban areas 8. No support for social development: health, education, etc (eg:) ~9 lakh anganwadis, only ~1 lakh are in urban areas 9. Laws not followed: despite manual scavenging being banned, it still continues 10. Political reasons: poor centre state/inter-state coordination (wrt migrants)
Counter-view: in some situations, "slums" are problems. In Dharavi, many slum dwellers have not used the redeveloped flats allocated to them, indeed sold them off, and slum habitation continues.
Way forward:
1. PM Awas Urban: slum redevelopment 2. Odisha's JAGA Mission: regularisation of slums by 30 sq ft title, possibility of slum buying additional land at market rates, provision of essential services, won UN-Habitat Livelihood Award 3. Transit oriented development 4. Empowerment of local bodies