Does selection leads to progress and ultimately to perfection? Discuss.
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
Natural Selection is defined as 'the multiple processes that lead to modification with descent', as per Charles Darwin.
As Darwin propounded his theory in 'The origin of species', it came to be believed that selection led to progress and 'ultimately perfection' as :
- Darwin himself gave the concept of 'Survival of the fittest' newer propounded that natural selection eliminates the weak and leads to progress. - Hominid evolution was believed to be towards perfection - Galton, Spencer etc described it as follows:
- Further social darwinism which was a pseudo scientific belief in superiority of societies like western as they were 'the fittest' lend credence to this idea. - Johann Blumenbach in 'The varieties of Humankind' provided that evolution led to progress and the ideal was caucasoid women
But this idea of selection as leading to progress has been debunked as follows:
- 'Progress' itself is subjective. what is progress in one environment may be a disability in another - e.g: Sickle cell gene leads to debilitating disease but in malarial regions is an adaptation as Hb[?] stops plasmodium - Hominid evolution itself just depicts the evolution of bipedalism due to increase in savanna in east African rift valley and not in vacuum.
- Natural selection has been shown to only lead to 'environmental adaptation' as showed by Synthetic theory - Genetic load itself which was considered as reducing perfection (by Haldane) is now considered as necessary for preadaptation - Further research by Reich, Svante Paabo et al has shown that selection is still operating to create 'well adapted' but 'not perfect' humans.
→ This needs a bio-cultural approach.
As Richard Dawkins argues selection leads to adaptation and 'perfection is only a construct'