Critically examine Leslie White's theory of cultural evolution
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
Leslie white was an American anthropologist who gave evolutionist theory of Tylor etc a new touch and formulated his 'Universal theory of cultural evolution' essentialy as cultural materialism phrased in energy terms.
Theory of cultural evolution
- He argued that culture is 'an extrasomatic continuum of things dependent upon symbolism' - For him, any cultural process can be analysed from the 3 perspectives : 1. The amount of energy captured. 2. The technology used to capture this energy 3. changes that this use brings in other parts of culture. - For him, the ultimate goal of all cultural activities is to capture energy. - He gave the cultural materialistic framework as follows :
- Infrastructure is the techno-economics used to capture energy - e.g: Muscle power in savagery stage - Social sphere : which consists of the social relations etc that are determined by infrastructure - e.g: Railway trade union based on Railway technology - Ideological sphere which consists of ideas, values etc such as religion etc - e.g: He described how even concept of 'beauty' is described/controlled by infrastructure. In cultures with food scarcity, 'fatness' in women is valued while as in modern cultures with enough food, 'thin and slim women' are preferred. - He thus describes the evolution of culture in terms of increasing energy capture or increasing means of capture as:
where 'E' is the energy captured with 'T' as technology and 'C' is the culture
Criticism
- Some practices of energy transfer such as breast-feeding is least & not technological. - Post modernists argued that 'there are no pancultural standards to measure culture' (Geertz) and we should be concerned with meanings not laws. - Julian Steward — argued that 'multilinear evolution' has been the theme of cultures not 'universal'.
Still the White's contribution was to move towards what he called as 'Science of culture not culture' & 'Culturology' in 'The science of culture',