Explain various forms of exchange systems in simple societies with the help of appropriate examples
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
Karl Polanyi in his work 'The Great Transformation' described in detail the meaning of exchange which is the 'change of redistributed output into one's own needs' by exchanging. He described the various types as
1. Reciprocity which is the 'mutual give and take of goods and services' Marshall Sahlins considered it to be of 3 types : 1. Generalised : based on no expectation of return. - e.g : !Kungs have generalised reciprocity in Scarce conditions (Richard Lee) 2. Balanced reciprocity : described by Hormigman as 'giving something for something else at a specified date/time' - e.g : Kula exchange as described by Malinowski in Trobriand with exchange of Mwali and Soulava - silent trade of Sembaga 3. Negative reciprocity described as 'where the parties try to gain at others expense'. Can range from barter to trade - e.g: Stealing among Navajo 2. Redistribution which is 'when people give to a chief who then distributes it' Usually of 3 types : briefly redistribution (found in Uganda) ; Bigman Bigwoman redistribution (e.g: Polynesia) and Potlatch (Kwakiutl as studied by Franz Boas). - Jared Diamond called it 'Kleptocracy' - Johnson & Earl called it an 'Earlier form of taxation' 3. Market exchange described as 'exchange in which the process is realised by use of currency' e.g: Modern societies ; tribals such as Iroquois (due to globalisation) - Jared Diamond argues that it has 4 principles , Barter , Market principles, currency, Exchange
-This shows the substantivist view of embeddedness in tribal societies.