Topper Copies

Nomothetic & Ideographic methods in Anthropology

Waseem Ahmad Bhat

A basic debate in anthropology is regarding the 'Search for universal laws' vs 'search for meanings' in socio-cultural studies which is also Nomothetic & Ideographic methods

Nomothetic methods

- Use of etic approach to formulate 'universal laws' of culture which can be applied to any culture. 1. Marvin Harris argues that etic approach allows anthropologists to use the data language of science & this is the only way to create nomothetic theories that can apply to all places. 2. Leslie White in 'The science of culture' argues that nomothetic methods can lead to 'science of culture and not cultures' which he called as 'anthropology'

On the other hand anthropologists such as Geertz, Tylor, etc argued that anthropology should focus on meanings and 'study of ideas' as culturally is a cognitive phenomenon.

This debate permeates all branches of anthropology and is a irreconcilable perennial as per Tom Campbell. Thus, an integrated approach is needed