Why do traditions in our society impede change? To what extent can social legislation be instrumental against old customary practices?
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
Traditions refer to practices continuing in society since a long period of time.
Traditions often impede change due to:
1. Inertia: it is easier to keep doing what one has been taught, what one is used to 2. Fear of unknown leading to resistance to change: often the feeling is "why change something that ain't broken? What if the change does not work?" The uncertainty leads to resistance 3. Lack of understanding about change (eg:) rapid change being brought about by technology 4. Fear of loss of control: - loss of social control (eg:) patriarchal institutions - loss of political control (eg:) caste based politics 5. Fear of becoming redundant after change (eg:) fear amongst traditional village associations of becoming redundant post formalization of Panchayati Raj 6. Religious organizations prevent change that impacts their standing 7. Perverse incentives (eg:) resistance of quacks to formalisation of AYUSH medicine
However, in some cases, tradition is not against change (eg:) blend of tradition and modernity in Indian culture, represented by fusion of yoga with other practices: laughing yoga, dance yoga, power yoga, etc.
Extent to which social legislation may help
Social legislation can help, but ultimately change has to be accepted by society:
1. Can help in case of crimes against women (eg:) sati abolition, dowry prohibition, etc, as society has now accepted the inhuman nature of crimes against women 2. Can help in social change: Beti Bachao Beti Padhao, Swachh Bharat 3. However, if it is radical change, likely to break resistance
Thus, more important is behavioural change. According to nobel prize winning Richard Thaler, any change needs 4 components: education, legislation, nudge, enforcement. Thus, legislation is only 1 component; need the other 3 too.
Case study: Swachh Bharat: - Education -> awareness - Nudge -> public shaming - Enforcement -> fines - Legislation -> All India ODF+ Policy