Topper Copies

Is industrial development in India a bane or boon to the agrarian class structure? Substantiate your answers with suitable examples

Waseem Ahmad Bhat

Agrarian class structure is defined by P.C. Joshi as the relationship between those who have the land & those who have the productive capacity to till it.

Daniel Thorner has given the typology of the traditional agrarian class structure in India: 1. Maalik (landowner) — Upper caste, Land owning class; absentee landlord. 2. Kisan (peasant) — Middle Caste; Small & marginal farmer. 3. Mazdur (labourer) — lower caste; work in others fields.

Since independence, due to more focus on industrial development since the 2nd Plan, the share of agricultural to GDP has reduced to around 18% of GDP and industry to > 25% of GDP.

Industrial development : Bane - led to increase in access to credit from formal sources.

e.g: From <10% at independence to more than 40% of credit now is from formal sources. - Technology and HYV seeds have increased productivity => Food security

e.g: Green revolution increased the incomes of peasants of western India - Farm mechanisation

- More opportunities for lower classes like Mazdur

Negatives - According to P.C. Joshi, it has led to: 1. Exploitative land lease agreements 2. Embourgeoisement of some & proletarisation of many. - Tilche in his study of Patidars of Sundaram found that leaving agriculture through education, emigration is important to status calculations today. - A.R. Vasavi — has argued that it has led to farmer suicides due to rising input costs of HYVs etc. - Disguised employment

Thus industrial development is a double edged sword for agriculture.