(c) Which is more significant, the principle of 'hierarchy' or the principle of 'difference', in the intercaste relations in the present day?
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
According to C. Bougle, the three most important characteristics of intercaste relations are: 1. Hierarchy 2. Mutual repulsion 3. Inter-dependence
Hierarchy vs. Difference - In traditional Indian Society, both hierarchy and difference was maintained through the concept of 'Purity & pollution' as said by Louis Dumont - Difference due to difference in attributes like vegetarianism, teetotalism, etc led to hierarchy in the form of caste ranking.
Present day - There is a change in the caste rankings due to Sanskritisation, dominant caste, etc which has decreased the effect of hierarchy. - M. N. Srinivas has argued that now caste system is dying but caste is not. This because, Castes are undergoing horizontal consolidation which leads to more differences. - But Louis Dumont argues that hierarchy is here to stay and hence caste is here to stay.
What can be said is that Caste has lodged itself into competitive politics & turned into more of a difference