Critically discuss the constitutional safeguards for the Scheduled Castes
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
Scheduled Castes are castes, tribes or races that are declared by the President of India under Article 341 of the constitution.
Formation - Usually from the untouchable category of Hindus — i.e., Dalits.
Constitutional Safeguards - Article 15(4) — Government can make special provisions for them. - Article 15(5) — Government can provide for special provisions in admission even in private Schools. - Article 338 — National Commission for Scheduled Castes. - Article 335 — Provision for inclusion in services based on the unrepresentation keeping in mind the efficiency of administration. - Art 339 — Commission for Scheduled castes. - Art 15 — Discrimination against them is prohibited - Art. 16(4) — Special provision for SCs in public employment. - Art. 17 — Prohibits untouchability
Evaluation 1. Positives : - Untouchability has reduced to a large extend.
e.g: A survey showed that 70% said that they don't practise it. - Increase in education :
e.g: Literacy has increased to 59% ; GER in higher education to 20%. - Representation : in civil services, government, etc has increased.
e.g: Reservations in Legislatures at centre & State.
2. Negatives : - Increase in violence
e.g: 7.3% increase in 2019 (NCRB) - Still face discrimination in all spheres
e.g: B.D. Sharma in 'Dalits Betrayed' argues that they have still not been mainstreamed. - Life expectancy 3 years lesser than higher castes - Recent research in PNAS (2022)
As B.D. Sharma has argued we need to change our model of development to lead to their economic development.