Topper Copies

Is Tribe-Caste Continuum a reality or myth?

Waseem Ahmad Bhat

The concept of Tribe-Caste Continuum was given by F.C. Bailey in his work 'Tribe, Nation and State' (1960) on the basis of Folk-Urban Continuum of R. Redfield

Bailey found out that tribes and castes were part of a continuum with some tribes as close to caste e.g: Odias

Tribe - caste Continuum as a reality

A debate has raged as to its empirical reality

- Surajit Sinha in his study of 'Bhumij of Balabhum' found out that they adopted caste features and were later accepted as Khastriyas a, a process De called 'Kshatriyasation' - Haimendorf found out that Hill Reddis came into Contact with plain people and accepted the Plough cultivation - N.K. Bose argued that when tribals come into Contact with powerful castes, they leave their culture & become castes —— a process called 'Hindu method of tribal absorption' - Others like G.S. Ghurye and Majumdar also argued the same.

Tribe-Caste Continuum : A myth

- Srivastava studied Hill Bhotias & he argued that what happens is cultural approximation, a process where mutual coexistence is rendered possible by acculturation. - David Mendelbaum argued that it is only because the ecological carrying capacity of tribal niches ends which causes them to migrate to other areas.

Tribe - caste Continuum : Relevance and Compromise

- Both castes & tribes can adopt each others features and transform e.g: Tribalisation as studied by Majumdar in Khasas shows it as a two way process. - NMSC of L.P. Vidyarthi shows that tribals can resist the domination of great tradition.

Thus as McKim Marriot argues processes of universalisation & parochialisation ensure integration of Indian civilisation