Topper Copies

Discuss the attributional and interactional theories of caste

Waseem Ahmad Bhat

Various understanding of caste has developed in India including attributional theory of Louis Dumont and interactional theory by McKim Marriot

Attributional theory of Louis Dumont

Louis Dumont based on his idea of 'purity & pollution' dynamic of caste gave this theory as follows:

- Various attributes are considered as 'pure' and 'impure' - Pure attributes are Vegetarianism, teetotalism, ban on widow remarriage etc. - Impure attributes are alcoholism, beef eating, equality of wife etc.

Dumont argued that based on those attributes, various castes are placed in a hierarchy with pure at the top and impure at the bottom.

- within these broad framework, various attributes can be used to put one caste over other

e.g: Vegetarian caste widow remarriage below vegetarian caste with ban on widow remarriage

[a pyramid in a box divided into four tiers, Brahmin at the apex and Shudra at the base]

- Hence, hierarchy is region-specific

Interactional theory

McKim Marriott criticised Dumont's theory as it couldn't delineate the exact hierarchy.

- He gave the theory based on what he called as 'Coded bodily substances'. Those at the top will only accept food in a very perfect form eg: Brahmins don't take cash but only pure food. - Those who provide the food are lower in Status - Hence, caste status is defined by interactions of castes with each other along with giving and taking of ritual status through food.

These understandings have been criticised later with village studies:

- M.N. Srinivas argued that status is based on numerical majority, land etc in his study of Rampura village - S.C. Dube argued that multiple attributes like caste, religion, individual determine

But these understanding have helped to develop a holistic view of caste