Discuss the Alliance-Descent debate in Anthropology
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
As Kinship is the basis of Social structure, a debate in anthropology ensued as to whether descent or alliance were the basis of the Social structure. In this regard, the following two theories came up:
Descent theory
It came up in 1940s with the publishing of 'The Nuess' by E. Pritchard and 'African Political Systems' by Meyer Fortes & E. Pritchard It sort of fizzled out in 1960s. Adam Kuper have divided the development of descent theory into two major parts - classical and Modern
Classical
- Henry Maine in Ancient law (1861) put forward the theory that society was based on patriarchal family which lead to lineage and later on territory. - Mclennan & L.H. Morgan argued that promiscuity lead to matriliny which lead to patriliny. - Franz Boas' students John Swanton and Frank Speck in their empirical research found L.H. Morgan proposition as wrong as family was present in even Algonkian hunter gatherers - R.H. Lowie established that family was present at all times
Modern
- Radcliffe Brown argued that society needs endurance and hence family led to corporate lineages e.g: Australian aboriginal tribes.
In opposition to descent theory, Alliance theory came up.
Alliance theory
Propounded by Levi Strauss in 'Elementary Structures of Kinship'. According to him, alliance, not descent forms the basis of Social Structure.
Due to binary opposition, incest taboo is created and it propels exogamy and positive marriage rules which lead to exchange of women and hence alliances between different groups. This he called as 'Elementary Structures of Kinship'
The two main types of elementary Structures of Kinship are:
1. Restricted exchange in which there are only two groups exchanging women e.g: moeities among many tribes.
2. Generalised exchange in which groups are multiple and wife givers are not the same as wife-takers.
In modern anthropology, debate has moved beyond descent vs alliance to descent and alliance.