Topper Copies

Distinguish between Economics and Economic Anthropology

Waseem Ahmad Bhat

'Economic anthropology' was coined by N.S.B. Gras in 1927 who defined it as the 'Synthesis of anthropological and economic Studies' in which we study the living of the primitive man.

As the definition clearly shows that economic anthropology is more than just economics or anthropology, there are various differences among the same:

1. While economics takes rationality in a very narrow sense, economic anthropology takes it in a very broad sense in the form of Social relations, Kinship etc 2. While economics Studies modern societies as a subject matter, economic anthropology usually focusses on primitive Societies 3. Economics as a discipline is based on the principle of utility maximisation. Same is not the case with economic anthropology where economic decisions are considered to be taken not only for utility maximisation but Social prestige, relations, etc. e.g: Potlatch 4. Economics studies the economics in terms of individual actors while as in economic anthropology group is usually taken as the unit. 5. Economics usually based itself on theoritical foundations while economic anthropology used empirical evidence in the form of ethnographies, etc. 6. Economics studies the economics in isolation while as economic anthropologists consult psychologists, sociologists, etc to come to a holistic conclusion. 7. Economic usually focusses on 'micro' or 'macro' at different time but eco. anthropology does that at the same time.

Although there are differences as shown above, there are similarities also:

1. Formalist school of economics (Heeskovitz, Schneider, Goodfellow) have borrowed the theoritical foundations from economics. 2. Behavioural economics developed as a subdiscipline of economics using inputs of economic anthropology.

As Chris Hann & Keith Hart put it in their work 'Economic anthropology' that time is ripe for anthropologists to address the world economy as a whole so that economic anthropology emerges as a disciplne in its own right.