Is the family universal? Critically examine how various anthropologists viewed the Family.
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
Family has been defined by George Peter Murdock as a group characterised by economic cooperation, Co-residence and reproduction. And it includes both of the sexes, atleast two of whom have a Socially approved Sexual relationship'.
GP Murdock did a survey of 250 Societies and found that nuclear family was a universal institution, as it performed the important functions of Society. These were: (i) Economic cooperation (ii) Socialisation of child (iii) Reproduction (iv) Sexual gratification.
David Abrele considered these four functions as the 'Prerequisites of the Society', as without them, Society can't function.
Criticisms
There have been various criticisms:
1. Kathleen Gough studied Nayars and found that they had matrilocal families and father's role was almost absent. 2. Harold E Driver in 'Indians of North America' argued that their societies were matrilocal with father's role as absent. They didn't have any nuclear family. 3. Judith Blake in 'Families of Jamaica' found that Carribean societies had matrifocal families and father's role was seriously modified. Sexual relations were performed by 'transitory males'. 4. Melford Spiro in his work 'Kibbutz: A venture in utopia' argued that in Kibbutz, children were raised communally by a trained nurse. Also economic cooperation was done on community level not family. Only function that parents provided was: nurture and Socialisation i.e., psychological and emotional warmth in the early years of life. 5. Malinowski in his work 'Argonauts of the western Pacific' also argued that they had matrilineal families and except perhaps for nurture and Socialisation, mother's brother did the major part in making the child learn. 6. Ira Reiss also found that nurture and Socialisation was done by family. She defined family as a 'small kin structured group that does the nurture and socialisation of the newborn' and this nurture and socialisation forms the bedrock of the personality system of an individual.
Hence, by making adult-role performance possible, nurture and socialisation is the pre-requisite of the society. It is the universal function of the family and hence family, in some form or the other, is universal.