Ethnocentrism vis-à-vis cultural relativism
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
The concepts of ethnocentrism & cultural relativism are two approaches with both similarities & differences :
Differences
| Ethnocentricism | Cultural relativism | |---|---| | W. G. Sumner described it as those ways in which one's group is the centre and other groups are hated and scale with respect to it. | It is described as objective study and explanation of cultural phenomena without any judgement | | It hinders anthropological study | It is dear to anthropologist as it leads to objectivity in ethnographies | | 3 types | 3 types | | Positive - one's group is preferred - gives one identity | Descriptive - objective description of cultures | | Negative - Negative view of other cultures | Normative - These are no extracultural standards to measure culture. e.g.: Franz Boas, Malinowski etc | | Extreme negative - tries to control other group & decides its culture | Epistemological - Cultures are mutually incomprehensible. e.g.: Geertz, Rosaldo, etc |
Similarities - Both are extremist views - Both might lead to lack of scientific objectivity
It is imperative that objectivity is maintained in ethnographies to ensure scientific study of cultures.