Topper Copies

Discuss opposing views of cultural relativism and universal human rights

Waseem Ahmad Bhat

The charter of Human Rights contains that these rights are not subject to traditional & cultural norms. This has led to its clash with cultural relativism

As cultural relativism presupposes that there are no extra-cultural standards to judge cultures, universality of human rights become an antithetical proposition and is not able to hold.

Several anthropologists have opposed cultural relativism as it is not in sync with individual rights. Edward Zechenter has build a powerful proposition in her work 'In the name of culture: Cultural relativism and the abuse of individual'.

According to her, cultural relativism leads to a confusion between the culture and the dominant voices in that culture. Hence, the voices of weaker sections are not taken into account She has given two examples to substantiate her point : 1. Egyptian Holy warriors (1992) : Sherif Kosambi, an Egyptian radical cleric gave a call to the young radicals to rape and murder those girls who go to school and in that year around 112 women were raped and even murdered. This was justified in the name of cultural relativism. 2. Indian Sati (1987) : In 1987, Roop Kanwar, a young Rajput girl died in sati when her husband died. It was unclear who did it. women's rights groups marched against the custom and demanded equal rights. On the other hand, Rajput men and women came out and justified it in the name of culture.

This clearly shows that voices of parents of those children in Egypt & Roop Kanwar in India were not taken into account.

Zechenter further argues that cultural relativism has been used to modify and dilute many international conventions e.g.: Convention to Stop all forms of violence against women has been modified to include cultural practices.

According to Zechenter, Universal rights establish a floor below which no Society should fall.

Paul Rosenblatt has argued that cultural relativism can help in ensuring cultural change as it promotes understanding.

Ultimately universal human rights charter, with all its flaws is the only avenue available to individuals for their intra-culture struggle for fairness and hence should be promoted