Topper Copies

Discuss the theoretical perspectives on incest and taboo in the 19th and early 20th century in anthropology

Waseem Ahmad Bhat

Incest taboo is one of the most important and universal of the prescriptive marriage rules among human society. It prohibits sexual relations between people in certain biological relationships. Although incest taboo is a universal taboo but what it entails is culturally specific. e.g: Cross cousin marriages are allowed within Muslim society but not within Hindu society. The most universal of incest taboo relates to the following relationships - Father-daughter, Brother-Sister, Mother-Son etc But many exceptions have been documented by anthropologists over time: 1. Prevalent among royal societies of Inca, Egypt etc for economic & religious reasons. 2. According to Durham (1991), between 30 Bc & 328AD, even commoners marriages in Egypt were brother sister (upto 8%) 3. Napolean Chagnon found that incest was quite widespread among Yanamamos of Brazil. 4. Anna Meige and Katholene Barlow found that in western Societies, father-daughter incest was common.

Even with these exceptions, no modern Society accepts incest among close Kin in nuclear family. Various anthropological perspectives have been provided for that:

1. Inbreeding avoidance theory by L.H. Morgan: According to this, incest taboo is universal so as to ensure that genetic defects dont increase in the progeny. Natural Selection ensured displacement of Societies with incest with Societies with incest taboo. Criticism : - How did traditional societies know about genes?

2. Because Familiarity theory by Edward Westermark: According to this, people who grow-up together lose sexual interest in each other as they are like 'open-books' to each other. Two case studies have supported this: - (i) Study of Kibbutz children by Yonina Talmon: She found that kids who grew in the same peer group had little sexual interest in each other. - (ii) Study of Taiwanese marriages by Arthur Wolf: Found that child marriages are less successful due to sexual disinterest. Criticism : - what was the need for taboo if it is natural ?

3. Family disruption theory by Malinowski: According to this, Sexual competition would have led to breakdown of family which will disrupt the enculturation process. Hence, Society imposed incest taboo on family Criticism : - Why couldn't there be any other way to ensure Survival of family !

4. Alliance theory by Levi Strauss: Given by E.B. Tylor & expanded by Levi Strauss, it propounds that incest taboo leads to pumping out of women out of family leading to formation of alliances ('Marry out' or 'Die out'). Criticism : - There is no evidence for the peacefulness because of incest taboo.

Whatever its origins, incest-taboo's benefits like genetic variability, alliance formation, etc have led to its persistence.