Topper Copies

Explain various anthropological approaches to study religion

Waseem Ahmad Bhat

Religion as a cultural universal has been an object of anthropological inquiry since time of E. B. Tylor, who defined it as 'belief in spiritual beings'

Various approaches have developed to its study:

1. Evolutionary approach

This focused on genesis and evolution of various forms of religion:

(i) John Lubbock — described the evolution as Atheism → Animalism → Fetishism → Nature worship → Polytheism → Monotheism → Ethical monotheism. (The origins of civilization)

(ii) Anthony Wallace — described it as Communal → Shamanic → Polytheism → Monotheism.

(iii) E. B. Tylor in 'Primitive Cultures' (1871) described it as Animism → Fetishism → Nature worship → Totemism ↓ Monotheism

2. Psychological approach

Since 20th century with the rise of psychoanalysis by Sigmund Freud, this approach was formed.

=> Emotive theories described religion as a profound emotional response to different aspects of nature:

(i) Fear -> William Wundt argued that fear of death etc lead to religion

(ii) Emotional appeal -> William James argued it had a profound emotional appeal.

=> Sigmund Freud's psychoanalytic theory described religion as due to oedipus complex which created problem between father and son. Totem came as a father substitute to repress the guilt of killing father

=> R. R. Marett -> described animatism as the first religion and it was 'not so much based on fear but awe' and 'not so much thought out as danced out'

3. Functional approach

which described religion as an institution to fulfil some bio-psychological need.

(i) Malinowski argued that religion reduces anxiety and fills knowledge-power gap. e.g: Mortuary rituals of Trobriand reduce their fear of haunted by dead.

(ii) Talcott Parsons argued that religion integrates the people into larger unity

(iii) In India, M.N. Srinivas following Radcliffe Brown studied cosy religion using functional approach.

With the coming of 21st century, new approaches like Structural approach (Levi Strauss), Symbolic, neurological (Sam Harris) have come up that have influenced the studies & made them holistic.