Critically examine the contributions of Neo-evolutionary school in Anthropology
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
In the backdrop of criticism of evolutionary School of anthropology by diffusionists and functionalists, Neo-evolutionary School came up in 1930s to resurrect the evolutionary School in a new way.
=> Basic postulates -> Contributions
- Rather than lineal form of evolution as proposed by evolutionists like Tylor, evolution of cultures can be considered as a parabolic arc. - Evolution can be multilined rather than unilined as proposed by evolutionists - Julian Steward - Multilined evolution
- Gordon Childe → Universal evolution - Sahlins & Service
- Culture are an adaptation to the environmental problems. - cultural ecology by Julian Steward → Those parts of the culture that are closely related to natural phenomena e.g: Subsistence pattern. - Led to the cultural ecology school which formulated new methods like 'processual ecology' approach and actor based models
Contributions of Leslie White
- Energy capture as the basis of evolution of culture. - According to him, cultural evolution occurs as the amount of energy captured increases or the technological means of doing so increase.
(C: Culture, E: Efficiency, T: Technology)
=> Contribution of Julian Steward
- He described multilinear evolution as multiple lines of evolution based on his idea of cultural ecology and culture core - cultures with similar culture core in similar environments will follow similar patterns of evolution e.g.: china, Meso America etc
=> Contribution of Gordon v. Childe
- He described universal evolution as a general progression of cultures as : Savagery → Barbarism → Civilization - These were based on archaeological finds from Near East & Europe.
=> Criticism
- Culture Personality school argues that culture rather than being mere mechanical adaptation is the organic personality writ at large (Ralph Linton) - Post modernists have criticised it as according to them , cultures are worlds of meaning within themselves.
However, Neo-evolutionism gave a new theoretical paradigm to anthropology to formulate laws not just study meanings.