Discuss the methods of studying human growth with their merits and demerits
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
Studying human growth can be done using anthropometry and growth curves.
It can be of 3-types :
1. Longitudinal method
in which the same group of children are studied over a long period of time and growth is measured.
e.g: Count de Montbeillard did the first growth study of his son till 18th birthday in 18th century
Advantages - Will get both growth & growth rate (Growth curve, Velocity curve) - Can understand the effect of diseases etc on growth - Can register growth spurts - can study of growth stages (e.g: Juvenile etc)
Disadvantages - Cost is exorbitant - Requires skill & commitment - Parents of children may change the diet based on observations - may lead to Hawthorne effect
e.g: Bhalla and Kumar found in a study that those studied longitudinally grew faster than those studied cross-sectionally.
2. Cross-sectional method :
In which different aged children are measured only once in the study to register growth.
Advantages - Easier to implement - Fast & inexpensive - Provides all the data at once
Limits - only growth curves & not velocity curves - Can't study difference in growth due to diet etc. - only averages and not the divergence
Examples : Boas, Scammon performed cross-sectional studies.
3. Semi- longitudinal :
in which some children are studied constantly while others come and leave the studies ,
Advantages: Both growth & velocity of growth Can know both effect of diet on growth & absolute growth Easier to implement as less costly
Limits: Need skilled statisticians to integrate data Huge error margins Can't learn growth velocity of all
Growth studies have enhanced the nutritional anthropology and provided a holistic outlook to the discipline of anthropology