Topper Copies

What are the principal differences between relative and absolute dating? Discuss two methods of each and describe the advantages and limitations of each

Waseem Ahmad Bhat

Dating is the archaeological technique of finding out the chronological age or relative age of an archaeological finding.

Relative dating:

- Can only provide the age of an object with respect to another object. - Used in archaeological sites with Vertical excavation - Huge margin of error - Example - FUN Trio, Pollen analysis, Cesiatim [?]

Absolute dating:

- Provides direct chronometric date of an object - can be used anywhere. - lesser margin - Example - Carbon dating, Potassium - Argon, Thermoluminescence

=> Types of relative dating

1. FUN Trio

It is based on the amount of Fluorine or Nitrogen remaining in an object. This is based on the principle that objects absorb fluorine or nitrogen from the surrounding.

Advantages: Relative dating is easier; Used for the same site; can be used everywhere

Disadvantages: Soils may have different Nitrogen values; only provides relative age

2. Pollen analysis

based on analysis of pollen grains which gives an idea of the climate of that time.

=> Types of absolute dating

1. Carbon dating found by W.T. Libby

Based on the decay of C-14 (radioactive) to C-12 after the death of an organism. - Half life of C-14 → 5380 ± 50 years.

Advantages - Easy to perform - Can date upto 50,000 with less error - Can use on any organism - Useful to date human remains in Africa

Limits - C-14 % age may change - only upto 50,000 - Not on non-living things - May get Contaminated

2. Potassium Argon dating : where Potassium decay is used to estimate age → Potasium with half life of 1.3 bn. years gives the estimate.

Advantages - easier to use - To 1.3 bn. years - Used in East Africa

Limits - Can't be used except on Volcanic rocks - only in East Africa - Not on living beings