Topper Copies

Discuss the Anthropology's Role in Combatting Racism

Waseem Ahmad Bhat

Racism may be defined as the belief in 'pure racial types' to which the members of a population tend to. In history, it has been rooted in Studies of Aristotle, Plato etc

=> Anthropology has been a bulwark against the racist ideas even though earlier anthropologists believed in some of ideas e.g: [L. H. Morgan's] evolutionary scheme.

=> Role in Combating Racism

Racism is based on four foundations

(i) Blood purity :

Anthropological studies have shown that blood types vary geographically rather than racially & they differ more within populations than between them.

e.g: Blackfoot Indians have A blood group when all other Indians are O.

(ii) Skin color :

Racism argues that inferior races have darker skin color. But anthropology has shown that skin color is determined by intensity of Sunlight in the atmosphere. It is a compromise between Sunlight damage and vitamin D need.

e.g: Some South Indian tribes darker than Africans.

(iii) Intellectual ability :

While people like wrote 'The Bell Curve' which tried to show blacks as less intellectual ; Anthropologists decried the methodology

(iv) Cultural Contribution —> whites believe that their cultural contribution is more but studies by Arnold Toynbee show that racial intermixing has happened before every great civilisation e.g: Syrian, Indian etc.

=> Perspectives

(i) Charles Darwin argued that it is difficult to name a trait that can have similar variation among all groups'

=> Ashley Montagu in 'Fallacy of Race' argued that race has no biological reality but is a cultural construct. 'There are no pure races'

=> Richard Lewontin found that 85% of the variation is within groups than between them (only 15%)

=> Chris Stringer in 'The origins' argues that racial differences have only emerged due to adaptations to different environments in last 0.1 mn. years

=> David Reich has argued that 'pure racial types' is a myth & intermixture has happened throughout

Thus, UNESCO in its statement of 1952 pointed out 'we are one Species- Homo sapiens' and 'racial types' are not to be found.