Write notes on the following in about 150 words each: (a) Caste ranking in India
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
G. S. Ghurye in Caste and Race in India (1932) gave the characteristics of caste system, one of which is the Caste ranking or the hierarchy of castes.
Caste ranking
Origins of caste ranking 1. Mythical theory of Purusha-Sukta hymn argues that Brahmins were born from head of Brahma and others from lower body -> hence ranking 2. Karma theory - was a post-vedic development (Louis Dumont) argues that hierarchy is based on Karma in previous life.
Anthropological views 1. Louis Dumont gave the 'attributional theory' and argued that the more the 'pure attributes' a caste has, the higher its ranking. - Pure attributes — Vegetarianism, teetotalism, etc. 2. McKim Marriot gave the 'interactional theory' & argued that a caste which gets only 'pure coded substances' like food, ritual services has higher ranking. e.g: Brahmins donot accept food from lower castes.
Future prospects 1. Louis Dumont argues that hierarchy is here to stay → So caste is here to stay. 2. M.N. Srinivas argued that caste ranking is already dynamic in rural & urban India. - Dominant caste came to the top from middle. - Sanskritisation of many castes, etc e.g: Teli, etc
Caste ranking is a dynamic concept that needs to be studied with empirical fieldwork and emic perspective.