Topper Copies

Indian Paleolithic culture can neither be conceived chronologically homogenous nor as a uniform cultural phase. Discuss.

Waseem Ahmad Bhat

Indian Paleolithic started in the upper Pleistocene from [?] 5 lakh years ago to 100,000 years ago. There have been a lot of findings in Paleolithic strata in India but it is neither chronologically homogenous nor culturally uniform.

Chronological non-homogenity

This can be seen from the following points:

- Until 1970s, there was a lot of confusion about inner division. - Subbarao and Bridget Allchin argued that Indian Paleolithic could not be divided into three phases due to following reasons: 1. River valleys only reveal two cultural layers 2. No bone-tools and art found to correlate with upper Palaeolithic as in Europe. - Later on, Sites like Bhimbetka, etc revealed the full chronological sequence when excavated by V.N. Mishra in 1973-76 - Also cave art was found in Bhimbetka, Adamgarh, etc.

This led to criticism of Subbarao and Allison's classification of only Early Stone Age and Late Age

[a vertical column of cave layers numbered 1 to 8, with a scale marking Mesolithic, upper Palaeolithic, Middle Palaeolithic and lower Palaeolithic, captioned "cultural sequence of cave III F-23"]

- H.D. Sankalia has argued that Stone age should be divided into 4 phase: 1. Early Stone age - lower Paleolithic. 2. Middle Stone age - Middle palolithic 3. Late Stone Age - Mesolithic & upper Palaeolithic 4. New Stone age - Neolithic.

Cultural non-uniformity

1. Tool culture: - Ranges from chopper chopping in Soan in North to Hand axes in South India. - Change in material is also non-uniform e.g: Bhimbetka doesn't show any change from quartzite. - Bone tools are also very less. Only MCG caves show lot of bone tools in Upper palaeolithic (90% bone tools) 2. Art: - only present in a few places like Bhimbetke, Lakhudyar, etc.

Thus, Indian paleolithic needs to be researched further to decipher proper cultural sequence.