The decline of Harappan civilization was caused by ecological degradation rather than external invasion. Discuss
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
Harappan civilisation was a Bronze-age culture found in North-western India from 3300 BCE - 1200 BCE with mature phase at 2600 BCE - 1900 BCE.
Regional distribution
[a hand-drawn outline map of the Indian subcontinent marking IVC sites: Harappa, Mohenjodaro, Ropar/Rakhigarhi, Alamgirpur, Kalibangan, Dholavira, Lothal, Surkotada]
Decline of Harappan civilisation
1. External invasion
Hypothesised by Wheeler, Piggot, etc.. According to this, Harappan civilisation declined due to invasion by Aryan race from Central Asia, around 1500 BCE
Evidence for:
- Battle of Haryupiya written in Vedas might point to Harappa. - Bodies and weapons found in Mohenjodaro debris were killed by Aryans. - Indra, the Aryan god, was known as Purandra i.e., Breaker of the forts which might have been Harappan walls.
Criticism:
- There is no evidence that Aryans migrated at 1800 BCE when Harappa was declining. - Bodies found may have naturally died out. - Harappa declined long before Aryans came in 1500 BCE, 300 year gap.
The more accepted theory is
2. environmental degradation theory (or climate change theory) - Given by Raikes and Dales. They argue that climate change around that time might have led to droughts which led to decline.
Others are:
3. Hydrologic theory - given by , which argues that shifting of Indus led to destruction of the civilisation. 4. Lighting theory by Dmitriyer argued that decline happened because of toxic physico-chemical explosion
Tony Joseph in 'Early Indians' argued that reasons might be plural but major reason was ecological degradation.