Topper Copies

Explain the basic features of 'Postmodernism' in Anthropology

Waseem Ahmad Bhat

Post-modernism [?] developed in anthropology in 1980s as a reaction to the modernism which considered the world as knowable through detachment (i.e., objective methodology).

The main scholars of this branch were: Michel Foucault, Jacques Derrida, Stephen A. Tyler, Clifford Geertz, Renato Rosaldo; etc.

Lyton divided postmodernism into two sub-branches - 1. weak postmodernism - represented by Foucault, etc 2. Strong postmodernism - represented by Derrida, etc

The main postulates of postmodernism in anthropology are :

- Traditional ethnographies are non-representative as they are full of biases : - Derrida described how ethnographies were full of implicit biases & he described the main problems with them : 1. Power - Traditional ethnographies came from powerful cultures hence leading to power asymmetry. 2. Voice - Traditional ethnographies are not an objective account as they are just one voice among many. - Renato Rosaldo described in his work 'Grief and the Headhunter's Rage' about 'Self reflexivity' where the 'author & objectifies the culture he studies and puts the actors in his own mental models' - Human knowledge is culturally determined : - Hans-Georg Gadamer described how all of human knowledge is gained through language which is determined culturally. Hence, knowledge can never be objective. - Foucault in 'Discourses of power' talked about how every social interaction is mediated by power and hence real knowledge is impossible to gain.

Postmodern suggestions for ethnography

- Deconstruction of texts - Derrida argued that deconstruction is to be done to lay bare the implicit assumptions of ethnographies, biases, what is said and unsaid, etc in ethnographies. - Deterritorialise ethnography - Lila Abu Lughod in her 'Tale of two pregnancies' deterritorialised ethnography by talking of both her experience of pregnancy as well as her Egyptian bedouin friends. - Demystify ethnography - Nancy Scheper Hughes in 'Hungry, Medicine & State' argued for demystification of ethnographic texts.

criticism

- Roy D'Andrade in his 'Moral Models' argued that they have misunderstood objectivity & as their models are moral models.

Postmodernism is just one flavour among the stew of anthropological theories and doesn't cause more harm than interdepartmental fighting