Discuss the theories regarding origin of spoken languages in human societies from both biological and cultural points of view.
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
Language is defined as a group of arbitrary symbols that a group uses to communicate (Black & Trager)
Human language origin has been one of the debated topics in anthropology and various hypotheses have been provided:
Divine theory
This hypothesis proposes that god endowed humans with the capacity to speak (Genesis).
Criticism: - No empirical evidence. - The mechanism is not explained.
Evolutionary theory
Scholars like Chomsky and Pinker have argued that during the course of evolution, humans acquired a the Language Acquisition Device (LAD) which helped them to speak.
Hyoid-Bone Complex
According to this, during upper-paleolithic, humans developed larynx and pharynx which helped them to speak.
Other developments were : 1. Development of Broca's and Wernicke's area in the brain. 2. FOX P2 gene which was recently discovered in humans is related to Basal ganglia development which is important for speech (especially vowels)
Socio-cultural
| Imitation hypotheses | Necessity hypotheses | |---|---| | 1. Ding Dong - Phenomena named after the sounds associated with them. e.g: crash for thunder, etc | 1. Warning hypothesis - used for warning each other especially while hunting. | | 2. Pooh-Pooh hypothesis - words came from involuntary exclamation of dislike, joy, etc e.g: Haha, etc | 2. Yo-he-ho hypothesis - words developed during cooperative efforts. | | 3. Bow-wow - words came from animal voices. e.g: Moo, bark, etc | 3. Lying hypothesis - E.H Sturtevant argues that language developed to lie in face of expressions which couldn't [?] |
Criticism: - Onomatopoeia (i.e., words from imitation) are only a small part of vocabulary.
Evolutionary theory is the most accepted presently as it is empirically demonstrable.