Examine the contribution of Margret Mead to culture and personality studies
Waseem Ahmad Bhat
Margaret Mead, one of the greatest American anthropologist, was a proponent of culture and personality school.
Main works
- Coming of age in Samoa . - Keep your Powder Dry : An anthropologists look at America . - Sex and temperament in primitive Society . - Photographic study : A relook at the Baliniese childhood .
Contributions
1. Culture affects personality
In her book 'Coming of age in Samoa', she described the adolescence of Samoan girls. She found out that adolescence in Samoa was characterised by a smooth transition because Samoan culture put little stakes on things like intra-marital / premarital sex, relationships were never serious, rape was uncommon, etc.
Among a group of 39 girls, she found out only 17 had heterosexual relations & 22 had homosexual experiences.
In her book 'Sex and Temperament in three primitive societies', she described how culture affected personality of people and the temperament of sexes.
- Arapesh who lived in a safe area were peace-loving, compassionate, less quarrelsome. Hence both men and women were submissive and helped in child-bearing. - Mundugumur who were quarrelsome, jealous, and insecure. They developed the personality of aggression. Both males and females were aggressive and were deceivers. - Tschambuli developed a personality where women were aggressive and men were submissive and cleaned the house and took care of the babies.
2. National character study
In her book 'Keep your powder dry', she took a look at the national character of USA through fieldwork.
3. Photographic technique
She used photographic technique to study Balinese especially childhood.
4. Re-study approach
She re-studied Manus of Polynesia in order to see the change in 25 years which led to interest in culture change
Criticism
- Derek Freeman in 'Margaret Mead & Samoa: The making and un-making of an anthropological myth' criticized her study of Samoa. - while she found free sexual relations among them, he found a strict virginity complex - while she found male-female love, he found male-female hostility. - Marvin Harris criticized her description of Samoan girls - She was criticized for her ideological tilt towards the left.
Despite criticisms, she had a huge influence on the latter Schools of anthropology and is still considered the greatest American anthropologist.