Topper Copies

The process of consolidation of Bengal, which started after the Battle of Plassey culminated in the Battle of Buxar. Do you think the Battle of Buxar was more important for the British than Plassey?

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

It is said that "Buxar confirmed Plassey", and that "Post Buxar, Bengal paved the way for the British conquest of India" - Bipin Chandra.

Culmination of process of consolidation of British power over Bengal, after Buxar:

1. In the Battle of Buxar, East India Company defeated an alliance of Md Qasim (Nawab of Bengal), Shuja-ud-Daula (Awadh) and Mughal emperor Shah Alam II 2. It led to the Treaty of Allahabad, which helped in consolidation of Bengal 3. Gave British power without responsibility in Bengal

Yes, it was more important for British than Plassey.

(i) Treaty of Allahabad:

1. Awadh used as a buffer state 2. British govt used Treaty of Allahabad to begin forming opportunistic alliances with zamindars (eg:) zamindar of Benaras 3. House arrest of Mughal emperor Shah Alam II

(ii) Symbolism of victory: defeated Shah Alam II (the Mughals), who were considered the rulers of India

(iii) Economic benefits:

1. Revenue from Bengal helped British in subsequent wars (eg:) used to fund Anglo-Mysore Carnatic wars, decisive advantage against the French state of Mysore 2. Opportunity to reduce trade deficit with India for East India Company by changing Bengal from a sellers market to a buyers market. EIC became "price setters". Re-industrialisation and de-urbanisation, market for British goods 3. Commercialisation of agriculture, forcible cultivation of Indigo

(iv) Military advantage:

1. Bengal used to station troops 2. Troops from Bengal used as reinforcements in Anglo-Maratha war

(v) Experience of using states as buffer states: based on Treaty of Allahabad with Awadh, this ultimately led to Subsidiary Alliance

(vi) Stable political capital in Calcutta, used as capital till 1911

(vii) Stable location to start anglicisation (eg) via English education, etc

Thus, while Battle of Plassey no doubt played an important role, for example during Carnatic wars, historians such as Bipin Chandra ascribe much greater importance to Battle of Buxar.